home | member's centre | contact
 
newsletters | May 2008 | français

 

Quick Links

The First Annual Atlantic Human Resources Conference
TAKING FLIGHT
Oct 1 – 3, 2008 in Moncton, NB!

HR’s Body of Knowledge Evolves with Business World
Of interest to those writing or thinking of writing one of the CHRP exams in October

HRANB Membership Survey Results

HRANB and CCH Canadian Partner to Launch PD Webinars

Message From CCHRA President

New CCHRA Staff

A Quiet Crisis Threatens Canadian Workplaces
Wilson Banwell

Paramedical services as a component of your organization’s wellness strategy
Jennifer Macmurray

Second Generation Harassment Solutions: A Two-tiered Approach to Awareness and Prevention
Dylan Hill

The Bench
Moira Goodfellow and Ryan Johnston

WHMIS - Education and Training
H. Pickard & Associates Safety Consultants

May 2008 Newsletter

A Quiet Crisis Threatens Canadian Workplaces
Wilson Banwell

Mental health conditions are depleting the human capital of Canadian companies.
A review of the research has shown that the cost of lost productivity and absence from mental health conditions is three to four times larger than the amount of dollars lost from healthcare and disability claims for these same conditions.

This is the conclusion of a comprehensive research review published in 2007 by Wilson Banwell PROACT Human Solutions.

The report, entitled The Quiet Crisis: The Business Case for Managing Employee Mental Health, draws from numerous studies on the impact of mental health in the workplace from around the world and synthesizes the key findings.

David Penney, Atlantic Region Director for Human Solutions, a major Canadian EAP provider, says that the report was a response to customer requests for factual, research-based recommendations to assist them with decision making and improving the health of their employees and their organizations. “Last year we wanted a concrete report that outlines for employers the most common mental health conditions that afflict large populations, the barriers to proper diagnosis, the treatment options, and what they can do to address this growing source of lost productivity and human suffering in their organizations.”

Mental health conditions, in particular depression, bipolar mood disorder, social anxiety and phobias, panic disorder, schizophrenia, and suicide, affect one in five employees. Unfortunately, two-thirds of these employees do not get any treatment, and of the third who do seek help, it most often is from primary care doctors untrained to treat mental health concerns. Employees with undiagnosed or under-treated mental health conditions often struggle valiantly to stay on the job. Despite their best efforts, many of them experience lapses in productivity, unscheduled days absent, physical illnesses, and alcohol and/or drug addiction.

Not surprisingly, the report finds that there is overwhelming research evidence of the critical role that mental health plays in the success of businesses of all sizes and all industries. The good news is that there is sufficient evidence to show that employers who take action and implement policies and practices that are supportive of the needs of those with work stress and mental health conditions, will realize significant dollar savings in the areas of reduced overall healthcare costs, reduced disability costs, fewer missed days from work, improvements in productivity, and lower turnover.

The report also states that studies show that “well-structured organizational approaches to improving mental and physical health generate effects that are stronger and longer lasting than interventions delivered at the individual level. Worksite-based preventative interventions seek to remove work-related practices and behaviours that contribute to employee stress and mental health conditions.”

A research review identified the following list of workplace attributes that contribute to both profitability and to better mental health:

  • Employment security
  • Self-managed teams
  • Decentralized decision-making
  • Extensive training
  • Reduced status distinctions
  • Reduced barriers to sharing financial and performance information across the organization

“In developing this report we focused on the value of a psychologically healthy workplace and what it takes to create one. The real significance of this document is that it provides the workplace with actionable steps they can take, regardless of how small or large they are, to address the stigma and discrimination that surrounds mental health concerns, and ensure employees get the right kind of help when they need it.,” Mr. Penney explains.

A PDF of the report can be obtained by emailing info@humansolutions.ca

Key Report Findings

  • When compared to all other diseases (such as cancer and heart disease), mental health conditions and addiction rank first and second in terms of causing disability in Canada, and they account for about two-thirds of all disability insurance claims.
  • Short and long term disability related to mental health conditions account for up to a third of the number of all claims and about 70% of the total costs – estimated to be well over $15 billion annually.
  • More employees are absent from work from stress and anxiety than because of physical illness.
  • Depressed employees are 20% less productive than non-depressed employees due to poor concentration, memory lapses, indecisiveness, fatigue, apathy, and lack of self-confidence.
  • Mental health conditions are widely experienced, especially in working age populations (1 in 5 employees in Canada). These conditions include depression, bipolar mood disorder, social anxiety and phobias, panic disorder, schizophrenia, and suicide.
  • In Canada, the percentage of the population aged 15-64 that have a diagnosable (i.e. clinically significant) mental health condition in any one-year period is approximately 12% (and twice that for lifetime prevalence.)
  • Approximately 45% of people with a mental health condition meet the criteria for multiple mental conditions. The most common pairings: depression and anxiety, bipolar depression and anxiety.
  • Thirty-three percent of Canadians with a diagnosed mental health condition also have a substance abuse problem.
  • On average employees spend 20% less time with family and/or spouse than they did 20 years ago.
  • Only one-fourth to one-third of Canadians with either a perceived need for care or with a diagnosis for a mental health condition actually got appropriate counselling-based treatment.

For the source of each of these statistics, please refer to the report document.